2026 Maritime Digest of Arbitration Awards and Court Rulings

Kelso Enterprises Ltd. v. LauritzenCool AB (The “St. Lucia”) – SMA No. 4208, 1 May 2013

COA — SEAWORTHINESS — CARGO DAMAGES — INDEMNITY — Owner Award

Charterer seeks market damages due to a one week delay in cargo delivery because of Vessel repairs. Owner rejects the Charterer’s damages claim on the basis that the Charterer sold the cargo under a CIF contract (title and risk of loss to the cargo is transferred when the cargo passes the ship’s rail at the loadport) and is therefore not the injured party.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Sangamon Transportation Group v. OSL Steamship Corp. (The “Genco Carrier”) – SMA No. 4206, 12 Apr 2013

NYPE — LOSS MITIGATION — UNSAFE BERTH — VESSEL DAMAGE — CHARTER HIRE RATE — PROTRACTED VOYAGE — WITHOUT GUARANTEE PROVISION — Partial Owner Award

The Disponent Owner’s claim was a summation of five different issues recapped below as (1) Vessel damage while alongside the discharge berth; (2) disputed daily hire rate for transit time to Santos to conduct repairs; (3) unsafe berth; (4) time charter trip exceeding the estimated voyage days fixed; and (5) indemnity for a third-party claim for underperformance attributable to bottom-fouling (due to prolonged waiting time at Charterer’s disport).

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Invista SARL v. Stolt Tankers BV (The “Stolt Perseverance”) – SMA No. 4205, 8 Apr 2013

ASBATANKVOY — COA — ARBITRAL VENUE — Charterer’s Motion Denied

Charterer requested arbitration hearings to be conducted in Houston, Texas, despite the Contract of Affreightment (COA) stipulating that arbitration is to take place in New York.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Clipper Holding (The Netherlands) BV v. Agritrade, LP (The “Sea Melodyr”) – SMA No. 4204, 29 Mar 2013

BALTIMORE FORM C — MOORING PERSONNEL STRIKE — PILOT DELAY — WIBON CLAUSE — NOTICE OF READINESS VALIDITY — SUBSTANTIAL READINESS — Charterer Award

The Vessel experienced serious delays en route to the upriver loadberth due to a strike of mooring personnel. Charterer rejected the subsequent demurrage claim, and at arbitration, they argued that (1) Shortened Proceedings should govern, (2) the loadport Notice of Readiness (NOR) was invalid because the Owner had not met all NOR requirements, and (3) the delay due to a workmen strike (mooring personnel) is exempted by a special exceptions clause.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Profindo Pte. Ltd. v. Abani Trading Pte. Ltd. (The “Athens”) – High Court, 14 Jan 2013

CFR SALES CONTRACT — DEMURRAGE — SHORT-DELIVERY OF GOODS — LOSS OF EARNINGS — DAMAGES — Partial Seller Award

Demurrage resulted when the port authorities forced the Vessel to leave the berth during discharge operations in order to berth a tanker deemed to be a higher priority. The CFR Buyer denied responsibility for the demurrage and excess port charges; and, counterclaimed against the CFR Seller for short-delivery of goods totaling 4 M.T. and unsatisfactory product quality. The Seller also claimed for loss of earnings resulting from the Owner blacklisting them due to the late demurrage payment and their resultant inability to fulfill a subsequent sale contract.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Falkonera Shipping Co. v. Arcadia Energy Pte. Ltd. (The “Falkonera”) – QBD (Comm. Ct.), 20 Dec 2012

BPVOY 4 — SHIP-TO-SHIP TRANSFER — BPVOY4 CLAUSE 8 LANGUAGE –VLCC-TO-VLCC TRANSFER — OWNER RIGHT OF REFUSAL — Charterer Award

Charterer instructed the VLCC vessel to discharge to two other VLCC’s (floating storage units) via a ship-to-ship transfer. The Owner withheld their approval of the Vessels and Charterer was forced to lighter to smaller vessels instead. Charterer argued that the Owner had breached the charter by wrongfully withholding their approval.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Breffke & Hehnke GmbH & Co. KG and Ors v. Navire Shipping Co. Ltd. and Ors (The “Saga Explorer”) – QBD (Comm. Ct.), 7 Nov 2012

BILLS OF LADING PHRASING — APPARENT GOOD ORDER — CARGO QUALITY — CONDITION OF GOODS — RETLA CLAUSE — COGSA — CONTRACT CONSTRUCTION — Consignee Award

The Vessel was chartered to carry a cargo of steel pipes. At the loadport, the cargo was inspected and found to be in poor condition as stated in the Survey report and Mates Receipt, however, the Bills of Lading reflected “apparent good order”. Consignee claimed for damages stemming from the misrepresented cargo condition in the Bills of Lading. Owner claimed that they were excused from liability under a protective “Retla clause” incorporated in the B/Ls.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

America Metals Trading, LLP v. Phoenix Bulk Carriers, Ltd. (The “Captain P. Egglezos”) – SMA No. 4201, 25 Feb 2013

GENCON — CONDITION OF PERFORMANCE — ADDITIONAL FREIGHT FOR REPLACEMENT VESSELS — Owner Award

Charterer seeks compensation for the freight differential paid on substitute tonnage when the Owner failed to perform in their obligation to nominate two vessels as required in the charter party. Conversely, Owner counters that due to cargo issues (railcar allocation, export documentation, etc.) and berth operational issues, the Charterer would not have been able to supply the cargo even if the Owner complied with the Vessel nominations.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Great Elephant Corp. v. CPC Corp. (The “Front Sabang”) – SMA No. 4197, 14 Dec 2012

ASBA II — GANGWAY FAILURE — SEAWORTHINESS –BAD WEATHER — DEMURRAGE — Partial Owner Award

The gangway collapsed during the boarding of the Charterer’s mooring team causing injury and subsequent delays in berthing. Per Owner, the cause of the collapse was due to a sheared swivel pin from contact by the tug in adverse weather. Conversely, Charterer asserted that the condition of the swivel pin was pre-existing and combined with the weight of the team caused the failure.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Carboex SA v. Louis Dreyfus Commodities Suisse SA – English Court of Appeal, 19 Jun 2012

COA — CARBOEX SA — LOUIS DREYFUS COMMODITIES SUISSE SA — DEMURRAGE — AMWELSH — PORT CONGESTION — STRIKE — PUERTO DE FERROL — SPAIN — SPANISH — HAULAGE STRIKE — INDONESIA — NOTICE OF READINESS — Charterer Award

Four vessels under a Contract of Affreightment (COA) experienced delays because of port congestion resulting from a strike that had ended prior to arrival. Charterer claimed that this time should be exempted as delays stemming from a strike, while the Owner argued that this exemption was only applicable if the strike had delayed operations after a given vessel had berthed.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.