2026 Maritime Digest of Arbitration Awards and Court Rulings

Isabella Shipowner SA v. Shagang Shipping Co. Ltd. (The “Aquafaith”) – QBD (Comm. Ct.), 26 Apr 2012

NYPE — TIME CHARTER — PREMATURE REDELIVERY — REPUDIATORY BREACH — Owner Award

Under a time charter contract, the Charterer redelivered the Vessel early and the Owner refused to accept the repudiatory breach in an attempt to affirm the charter party rather than the usual course of action in re-fixing and then claiming damages.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Great Eastern Shipping Co. Ltd. v. Far East Chartering Ltd. and Anr (The “Jag Ravi”) – English Court of Appeal, 9 Mar 2012

LETTER OF INDEMNITY – WRONGFUL DELIVERY – Owner Award

In upholding the Commercial Court’s ruling of 27 May 2011 (background details previously recapped in The TANKVOYager, Vol. 18, No. 1), the Court of Appeal held that the Owners are protected under an LOI issued by the Receivers to the Charterers. Despite the Owner being unaware of the LOI, the Owner was protected by it on the basis that the Owner was acting as the Charterer’s agents when delivering the cargo. The Appellate Court held that “delivery” is a legal concept that does not mean “discharge” and that the Owner need not physically hand over the cargo to the Receiver; rather Owner’s obligation was fulfilled by surrendering possession and power relating to the cargo when delivering to the port authority. With regard to the public policy argument in the Receiver’s attempt to preclude Owner’s protection under the LOI, the court held that the Owner was incapable of a deliberate wrongdoing as the Owner was unaware of a dispute between the sellers and the intermediate buyer; furthermore, this was deemed a commercial dispute (not a public policy issue).

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Eitzen Bulk AS v. TTMI SARL (The “Bonnie Smithwick”) – QBD (Comm. Ct.), 14 Feb 2012

SHELLTIME 4 — BUNKERS ON REDELIVERY — MEANING OF “PRICE ACTUALLY PAID” — CHARTER CONSTRUCTION — Owner Award

The Vessel was sub-chartered by the Charterer back to the Head Owner for a time period constituting the remainder of the head charter. Vessel redelivery would thereby take place simultaneously under the sub-charter and head charter, however, the proper bunker prices that each party was liable for at redelivery was up for contention.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Euroceanica (UK) Ltd. v. Crystal Amaranto and Tricon Shipping Inc. (The “Crystal Amaranto”) – SMA No. 4186, 21 Sep 2012

CRYSTAL AMARANTO — ASBATANKVOY — COMMERCIAL DAMAGES — MASTER’S ROLE — CONTAMINATION — CAUSTIC SODA — FREE MARINE LIMITED — UNCLEAN BILLS OF LADING — Owner Award

While loading Charterer’s cargo, the Master noticed signs of potential contamination. Surveyors would later support his findings however they could not ascertain the nature or source of the problem. The Master chose to clause the Bills of Lading to reflect the findings which caused a loss of sale to the Charterer. Owner brought arbitration to recover demurrage for lost time testing the cargo and the Charterer counterclaimed for commercial losses.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Team Tankers v. Noble Americas Corp. (The “Team Jupiter”) – SMA No. 4183, 31 Aug 2012

ASBATANKVOY — VESSEL COLLISION AND DECEPTIVE HANDLING — DEADFREIGHT — VETTING REJECTION — COMMERCIAL DAMAGES — Charterer Award

Without Charterer’s knowledge, the Vessel had suffered class-affecting damages while operating under a prior charter. As a result, the Vessel was rejected at discharge port by the Receiver’s vetting group and the Charterer was forced to make a distress sale at severe losses. Owner commenced arbitration proceedings to collect deadfreight and demurrage; Charterer counterclaimed for commercial losses.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Hess Corp. v. Leo Tanker Corp. (The “Atlantic Leo”) – SMA No. 4181, 31 Jul 2012

ASBATANKVOY — CARGO CONTAMINATION — TANK SEGREGATION — COGSA — MITIGATION — COMMERCIAL DAMAGES — Partial Charterer Award

Upon loading the Charterer’s two parcels of premium and regular gasoline, some of the premium was found to be below the Buyer’s required octane rating due to an apparent commingling of the two parcels. The Charterer mitigated their losses by deviating to an additional disport and discharging the unacceptable cargo there to be sold as regular. Charterer claims that the contamination took place on board the Vessel and that they were owed the difference between the Buyer’s price for premium and an average sampling of bulk regular pricing as proper mitigation.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Caribe Tankers, Ltd. v. Petroleo Brasileiro, SA (The “Negotiator”) – SMA No. 4165, 17 Feb 2012

SHELLVOY 6 — DEMURRAGE — DOCUMENT SIGNATURE — FAILURE TO ISSUE LETTER OF PROTEST — Charterer Award

After the Vessel loaded her cargo, the terminal representative refused to sign the Statement of Facts. When Owner submitted their demurrage claim after the voyage, the Charterer refuted it on the grounds that the missing signature invalidates the relevant loadport demurrage on the basis that Owner failed to issue a requisite Letter of Protest (LOP).

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Phoenix Bulk Carriers, Ltd. v. America Metals Trading, LLP. (The “Captain P. Egglezos”) – SMA No. 4164, 9 Feb 2012

GENCON — DEMURRAGE RATE — FORCE MAJEURE — REVERSIBLE LAYTIME — CHARTER CONSTRUCTION — Owner Award

At issue is whether the charter party allowed for reversible laytime due to the deletion of the ‘Non-Reversible’ Laytime Clause in a prior charter incorporated basis “logical alterations”. Also, Charterer claimed that Force Majeure was in effect at disport due to prior Hurricanes Gustav and Ike which allegedly caused delays in procuring barges.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Progress Bulk Carriers Ltd. v. Tube City IMS LLC (The “Cenk Kaptanoglu”) – QBD (Comm. Ct.), 17 Feb 2012

GENCON — ECONOMIC DURESS — REPUDIATORY BREACH OF CONTRACT — VESSEL SUBSTITUTION — Charterer Award

Although Owner’s action of substituting the contracted vessel without notifying the Charterer created a repudiatory breach, the Charterer did not cancel the charter. Owner proposed a new vessel and promised to reimburse the Charterer for damages, however they later used economic leverage to gain a better deal during renegotiation.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Hyundai Merchant Marine Co. Ltd. v. Trafigura Beheer BV (The “Gaz Energy”) – QBD (Comm. Ct.), 25 May 2012

SHELLTIME 3 — TIME CHARTER — SPEED WARRANTY — PERFORMANCE CLAUSE — UNDERPERFORMANCE — BUNKER CONSUMPTION — ALL WEATHER WARRANTY — Charterer Award

The sub-charterer contends that the time-chartered vessel did not meet the contracted requirements for speed and fuel performance basis the construction of the relevant clauses. Such construction is based on the inclusion of an all weather warranty, which the owners claim is not proper in the context of this time-charter.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.