2026 Maritime Digest of Arbitration Awards and Court Rulings

London Arbitration 12/13

TIME CHARTER — REPUDIATION OF CONTRACT BY CHARTERER — MEASURE OF DAMAGES WHEN NO SIMILAR MARKET EXISTS — Owner Award

After non-payment of hire for 10 consecutive months, Owner withdrew the Vessel and sought restitution from the Guarantor of Charterer’s liabilities for the unpaid hire up to the point the time charter contract was deemed repudiated, damages for the unexpired period remaining, and restitution for bunker costs.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Falcon Carrier Shipping, Ltd. v. ST Shipping and Transport, Pte. Ltd. and Glencore, Ltd. (The “Falcon Carrier”) – SMA No. 4217, 20 Sept 2013

SHELLTIME 4 — TIME CHARTER — OIL MAJOR APPROVALS — WRONGFUL EARLY REDELIVERY — MEASURE OF DAMAGES — Owner Award

At dispute is whether the Charterer’s clause requiring three Oil Major approvals throughout the duration of the time charter is ambiguous when blanket approvals are no longer given; and, whether Charterer’s early redelivery was wrongful.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Zurich American Insurance Co. and Vinmar International Ltd., Inc. v. Team Tankers AS and Eitzen Chemical (The “Siteam Explorer”) – SMA No. 4216, 26 Aug 2013

ASBATANKVOY — CARGO CONTAMINATION — CARRIAGE OF GOODS BY SEA ACT (COGSA) — Owner Award

Charterer alleged that their cargo of Acrylonitrile (ACN) was allegedly contaminated onboard the Vessel resulting in a yellowing to a color rating of APHA 13 (exceeding the maximum resale spec of APHA 10).

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Atlas Shipping AS v. Olendorff GmbH & Co. KG (The “Fomalhaut”) – SMA No. 4211, 8 Jul 2013

NYPE — CHAIN OF TIME CHARTERS — CONTAMINATED BUNKERS — WHETHER CHARTERER PREJUDICED BY FAILURE TO PARTICIPATE IN EARLIER CONSOLIDATED DISPUTE — Owner Award

After bunkering, the Vessel sailed to the next port prior to receiving the bunker test results showing that the bunkers were off-spec (after the bunkers were already partially consumed). At the consolidated proceedings, the Owner was deemed liable for the resultant machinery damage but was awarded costs for debunkering, tank cleaning, rebunkering, and associated costs. At issue in this dispute is whether the last Charterer in the chain, who freely chose not to participate in the consolidated proceedings, is liable to indemnify the Time Chartered Owner.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Trafigura Beheer BV v. Ravennavi SpA (The “Port Russel”) – QBD (Comm. Ct.), 1 Mar 2013

BPVOY 3 — NOR VALIDITY — DEMURRAGE — NOTICE OF READINESS BY EMAIL — Charterer Award

At issue is whether Owner may tender a valid Notice of Readiness (NOR) by email. The governing BPVOY 3 charter party, Clause 19, provides a list of six methods by which a valid NOR may be tendered – email is not one of them.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

London Arbitration 4/13

BIMCO PIRACY CLAUSE — TIME CHARTER — NECESSITY OF PIRACY INSURANCE — REIMBURSEMENT OF INSURANCE PREMIUM — Charterer Award

When the Vessel was instructed to sail on a voyage which took her through the Gulf of Aden — an area known to be exposed to piracy risks – the Owner undertook insurance against kidnap, ransom, and loss of hire for which they seek reimbursement for the $31K insurance premium. At issue is whether the insurance was “necessary” as stipulated in the BIMCO Piracy Clause.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

London Arbitration 2/13

NYPE — TIME CHARTER — BACK-TO-BACK CHARTERS — 1986 US TAX REFORM ACT — INEMNITY FOR US FREIGHT TAX — Charterer Award

Tax payable under U.S. Tax Code for transportation income earned by a nonresident alien or foreign corporation is potentially payable for the hire earned by the head owner as well as the income earned by the disponent owner, subject to any exemptions. In this instance the disponent owner was found to be exempt and, therefore, their request for indemnity from the sub-charterer had to fail.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

BP Oil International Ltd. v. Target Shipping Ltd. (The “Target”) – English Court of Appeal, 14 Mar 2013

BPVOY 4 — “REASONABLE” OVERAGE FREIGHT — INCORRECT FREIGHT CALCULATION — RECOVERY OF OVERPAYMENT — Owner Award

Owner and Charterer appealed a judgment that found Charterer was liable for a “reasonable” amount (subject to further inquiry) of freight that was overpaid on the Owner’s purportedly miscalculated invoice. At issue is whether freight overage applies for cargo carried in excess of the minimum volume stipulated when the additional port/region was not named in the Overage Section of the contract.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Westwood Shipping Lines Inc. and Another v. Universal Schiffahrtsgesellschaft mbH – QBD (Comm. Ct.), 25 May 2012

UNLAWFUL MEANS CONSPIRACY — CONFIDENTIALITY WAIVED — DISCLOSURE FOR JUSTICE — Claimant Award

Bdocuments that had been presented in a London arbitration were needed by the Claimant to pursue court proceedings against others for alleged unlawful means conspiracy.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Frescati Shipping Co., Ltd. v. Citgo Asphalt Refining Co. (The “Athos I”) – US Court of Appeal (Third Circuit), 16 May 2013

ASBATANKVOY — SAFE PORT WARRANTY — “APPROACH” DEFINED — Owner Award

Owner appealed the U.S. District Court ruling for exoneration from or limitation of liability resulting from the Vessel striking a partially submerged anchor in its approach to the Charterer’s discharge terminal. Per Owner, Charterer breached the safe berth warranty. Per Charterer, the incident occurred outside its area of control and the Owner is responsible for port draft restrictions by virtue of the port being named in the charter party.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.