2026 Maritime Digest of Arbitration Awards and Court Rulings

Schuyler Line Navigation Co. v. Trade Ferro Metal Inc. (FEMET) (The “Pacific Bangshen I”) – SMA No. 4062, 15 Jan 2010

GENCON — FORCE MAJEURE – DEMURRAGE — HURRICANE — BUNKERING — “ARRIVED SHIP” NOR — WIPON — NOR ACCEPTED WITHIN OFFICE HOURS — Owner Award

The Vessel arrived EOSP to discharge 179 miles up the Mississippi River shortly after the passage of Hurricane Gustav through the area which resulted in the closure of the river and Charterer’s terminal. Shortly thereafter, an upriver section of the river re-opened to traffic, but a draft restriction at the mouth of the river and berth congestion prevented the Vessel from proceeding to the discharge berth. Owner started laytime once the discharge berth re-opened following the hurricane. Conversely, Charterer rejected all waiting time basis the Agent’s SOF remark that the River was closed to navigation during presumably much or all of the waiting time; and, Charterer held that the Vessel was not an arrived ship when NOR was tendered because she later stopped her upriver transit to take on bunkers. Whilst bunkering, Charterer’s berth was unavailable.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Vertical UK LLP v. Dundee Ltd. (The “Nora”) – SMA No. 4051, 16 Nov 2009

ASBATANKVOY — WHETHER DEMURRAGE IS PAYABLE AFTER LOADING — REVERSIBLE LAYTIME — LATE ARRIVAL AT DISPORT — DAMAGES — Partial Charterer Award

With the Vessel arriving at the disport approximately 72 days later than projected for a customary 14-day voyage, the Charterer incurred $103K demurrage on two barges that were on standby to receive the cargo. After the Vessel arrived, Owner subsequently refused to discharge the cargo until Charterer remitted loadport demurrage. The issues decided by the Panel include liability of consequential barge demurrage and whether the Owner is entitled to collect demurrage prior to discharging when the fixture stipulates “reversible laytime”.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Agrifos Fertilizer, Inc. v. Transammonia, Inc. (The “Bow Heron”) – SMA No. 4049, 12 Nov 2009

ASBATANKVOY — FORCE MAJEURE — HURRICANE — WRONGFUL CANCELLATION — DUE DILIGENCE — Seller Award

The CFR Buyer declared force majeure after its Pasadena, TX facility was struck by Hurricane Ike and cancelled one of two CFR contracts with the Seller. The dispute concerns whether the event constituted force majeure within the context of the sales contract, whether the sales contract allowed Buyer to cancel the contract and whether Buyer’s steps to restore operations at its facility constituted the due diligence required.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Empresa Maritime Americana Ltd. v. View Point Global Petroleum, LLC (The “Lady Chiara”) – SMA No. 4048, 30 Oct 2009

ASBATANKVOY — FAILURE TO PROVIDE CARGO — DEMURRAGE — Owner Award

Owner seeks recovery of demurrage encompassing over 17 days that the Vessel spent awaiting cargo at the loadport which, despite Charterer’s repeated promises, the cargo was never forthcoming causing Owner to terminate the fixture. The Panel rules on a remedy for Owner’s lost time.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Novologistics SARL v. Five Ocean Corporation (The “Merida”) – QBD (Comm. Ct.), 27 Nov 2009

BERTH OR PORT CHARTER — WAITING TIME — CHARTERPARTY CONSTRUCTION — ONE SAFE BERTH — Charterer Award

With no incorporation of a proforma charter party form, at issue was whether the fixture constituted a berth charter or port charter. The key terms considered include “one good and safe Charterer’s berth” in conjunction with other clauses addressing a safe port warranty and shifting time. In overturning the arbitration award, the Court examined the fixture terms and explained contract construction.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Securing Assets for Maritime Claims in N.Y.: Pre- and Post-Judgment

For centuries, physical assets such as ships, cargoes, bunkers, and bank accounts have been seized to satisfy maritime commerce debts, before a judgment is rendered, whenever those assets were found within the court’s jurisdiction. Since maritime transactions are oftentimes international and transitory in nature, securing assets from a defendant can be achieved by the plaintiff appealing within the court’s jurisdiction and showing that the asset, whether it be a ship or cargo, is within the jurisdiction and that the defendant is not. In those cases, the attachment is granted. In turn, the defendant must appeal to the court to have the attachment vacated. If the plaintiff prevails, the value of the seized asset is secured.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Cobelfret Bulk Carriers NV v. Swissmarine Service SA (The “Lowlands Orchid”) – QBD (Comm. Ct.) 13 Nov 2009

CHARTERPARTY LANGUAGE “SHINC” — SUPER HOLIDAYS — ADDITIONAL CLAUSE SUPERCEDING PRO-FORMA – DESPATCH – DEMURRAGE — Charterer Award

This laytime dispute hinged on the interpretation of a fixture recap term, SHINC (Sundays and Holidays included), in conjunction with the terms of the underlying charter party form. The underlying charter party Clause 63 stipulated “Sundays and Holidays included”, followed by the phrase, “…excluding Super Holidays”. At issue is how the contract should be interpreted specifically relating to the terminal shutdown during the Christmas holiday period.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

AET Inc. Ltd. v. Arcadia Petroleum Ltd. (The “Eagle Valencia”) – QBD (Comm. Ct.), 8 Oct 2009

SHELLVOY 5 — NOTICE OF READINESS — FAILURE TO OBTAIN FREE PRATIQUE WITHIN 6 HOURS — Owner Award

With the charter party fixed on an amended Shellvoy 5 form inclusive of “Shell Additional Clauses – February 1999”, this dispute hinged on whether the Vessel’s NOR was valid in light of the fact that Free Pratique was not granted within six hours as specified within Shell Additional Clause 22.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

“Once on Demurrage, Always on Demurrage” ~Not a Fairy Tale~

The maxim “once on demurrage, always on demurrage”, although seemingly an innocent phrase, is not a fairy tale and is in fact, serious business. In order to understand this maxim one must first clearly define demurrage. In a strict sense, demurrage represents liquidated damages for delays associated with loading and discharging beyond the laytime contractually allowed. Applicable case law, both as court cases and in arbitration, holds that demurrage is extended freight and that the risk of circumstances which prevent the loading or discharge of cargo within the stipulated laytime lies unconditionally with the charterers. As explained in M/T “Raphael”, SMA No. 3739 (6/10/02), “this rule of ‘absolute liability’ for payment of demurrage is subject to three exceptions:

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

ENE Kos v. Petroleo Brasileiro SA (“The Kos”) – QBD (Comm. Ct.), 23 Jul 2009

SHELLTIME 3 — TIME CHARTER — UNPAID HIRE — WITHDRAWAL OF VESSEL FOR UNPAID HIRE — DETENTION OF VESSEL — CONSUMPTION OF BUNKERS — SECURITY — Partial Owner Award

The Court was called to determine if, following the Charterer’s failure to pay hire, Owner’s withdrawal of the Vessel during load operations was legal. If so, was the Owner entitled to damages or solely compensation for expenses (bunkers and time consumed discharging the cargo) incurred fulfilling their duties as bailee, plus the cost of securing the bank guarantee as required by the Charterer.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.