2026 Maritime Digest of Arbitration Awards and Court Rulings

London Arbitration 15/10

NYPE — TIME CHARTER — HOLDS REJECTED UPON DELIVERY — COST OF CLEANING — CAUSATION OF WAITING TIME — Part Owner Award, Part Charterer Award

Upon delivery the Vessel’s holds were rejected which subsequently took 6 days for cleaning and approval, followed by 4 days spent waiting to berth. The Panel ruled that Charterer was to be reimbursed by Owner for the cost of the cleaning and that only the delay specifically related to the holds failing inspection was to be for Owner’s account. Charterer was responsible for the berth occupancy upon the Vessel’s arrival and the berth occupancy once the Vessel’s holds were approved yet another vessel was brought in.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

London Arbitration 13/10

NYPE 1946 — VESSEL REJECTED DUE TO LACK OF COFR (CERTIFICATE OF FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY) — CALCULATION OF DAMAGES — Owner and Disponent Owner Award

When Owner failed to provide the COFR, Sub-Charterer and subsequently Charterer cancelled the Time Charter (hereinafter, “Charter”). Given that the applicable clause in the Charter and Sub-Charter provides a remedy for delay due to not having the COFR and said remedy does not include cancelling the Charter (or Sub-Charter as the case may be), Panel rules in favor of Owner and subsequently Charterer (also referred as “Disponent Owner”) with the party wronged to be put into the position they would have been in had the Charter and Sub-Charter been fulfilled. The damages to be awarded are basis the market rate versus the Charter and Sub-Charter rates, respectively.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

London Arbitration 11/10

GENCON — LAYTIME DURING PERIODS OF HEAVY SWELL — WEATHER WORKING DAYS — RESULTING SHIFTING EXPENSES — SAFE BERTH — Charterer Award

Basis a charter party stipulating cargo to be discharged at an average rate “per weather working day” the Panel determined laytime was not to count during a period of port closure due to Ressac swells. The Owner was responsible for the cost of unberthing and reberthing during the port closure as Charterer had not breached their safe berth warranty as the port closure was at the direction of the harbormaster and the Vessel was able to unberth and reberth safely.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

AOT Ltd. v Caribbean Petroleum Corp. (The “Cape Bruny”) – SMA No. 4073, 6 May 2010

SALES CONTRACT — FORCE MAJEURE — EXPLOSION — CUSTODY TRANSFER — DEMURRAGE — Partial Final Seller Award

During discharge, an apparent shoretank leak at Buyer’s facility caused an explosion which destroyed storage tanks inclusive of cargo being discharged and cargo discharged during previous deliveries not yet paid for by Buyer. The Buyer declared force majeure and contends that it is excused from paying for all cargo destroyed in the shoretanks, cargo remaining onboard the Cape Bruny yet to be discharged and the resultant demurrage.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Chevron Marine Ltd. and Chevron Products Co. v. Stena Bulk AB (The “Stena Conquest”) – SMA No. 4075, 17 May 2010

ASBATANKVOY — CARGO CONTAMINATION — BURDEN OF PROOF — DEMURRAGE CLAIM WITH RESPECT TO DELAYS — Owner Award

The first, second, and third foot samples of ULSD cargo were off-spec with respect to flashpoint (a key commercial criterion for this cargo) resulting in offloading and further Vessel cleaning. Although there was a dedicated line from the shore tank to the terminal manifold, an additive was injected at the terminal manifold (from bulk containers and drums) which could have affected the ULSD flashpoint. Thus, Charterer failed in proving by a preponderance of credible evidence that the Vessel’s tanks were the cause of the cargo damage. Furthermore, the burden is on the Charterer to prove that the Vessel did not exercise due diligence in tank preparation which he failed to do.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Demurrage is Not an Indemnity

Oftentimes, demurrage claims issued by commercial trading partners under contracts of sale are disputed and a copy of the ship owner’s demurrage claim is requested, allegedly to support the merit of the claimant’s invoice. However, unless the stipulation to provide the Owner’s claim is expressly required within the contract terms, it is unnecessary to be disclosed as demurrage is not considered an indemnity (compensation for a loss suffered). Contrary to popular belief that a party cannot benefit by demurrage, English law holds that there is an absolute obligation to pay demurrage incurred under the terms of a sales contract. There is nothing to prevent a profit from being made on a legitimate demurrage claim [Houlder Brothers Co. Ltd. V. Commissioner of Public Works [1908] AC 276].

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Emeraldian Ltd. Partnership v. Wellmix Shipping Ltd. and Anr (The “Vine”) – QBD (Comm. Ct.),17 June 2010

BREACH OF SAFE PORT WARRANTY — BEYOND CHARTERER’S CONTROL — WHETHER DELAY COUNTED AS LAYTIME — DEMURRAGE — Owner Award

After nominating the loadberth an accident occurred forcing its closure for repairs. Owner claimed demurrage for the time spent by the Vessel awaiting the repair of the berth, but Charterer refuted the claim basis the notion that the accident was beyond Charterer’s control. In addition, the Court was asked to determine whether the berth was safe at the time it was nominated due to the complex mooring maneuvers required in order for vessels to safely berth.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.

Cosco Bulk Carrier Co. Ltd. v. Team-Up Owning Co. Ltd. (The “Saldanha”) – QBD (Comm. Ct.), 11 June 2010

NYPE — PIRACY — CHARTERPARTY LANGUAGE — WHETHER VESSEL CAN BE CONSIDERED OFF-HIRE — Owner Award

Charterer appealed to have all time that the Vessel was held by pirates count as off-hire. The High Court examined whether the Vessel was prevented from working due to any of the three causes listed in the charter party: a) detention by average accidents to ship or cargo; b) default and/or deficiency of men; c) any other cause.

To access this post, you must purchase Annual Subscription or 2 Year Subscription.